Practical Magic Review

I’ve read two other Alice Hoffman books in 2020 — The Ice Queen and Blackbird House — and really enjoyed them. I have watched the movie (once, two years ago) and enjoyed it too. I would say the movie changed a lot of aspects, but both the book and movie versions of the story are enjoyable. I would disagree with other reviews saying the books is “completely different” from the movie, or saying that the book is “boring.” This story is full of action and introspection.

I have had really good luck with my spooky books for the autumn season and Practical Magic kept with the spooky theme. The magic in it is subtle and a little spooky, but the real spook was the plot about Gillian and her “turbulent” love life. She has had a string of toxic/codependent/abusive relationships and by the end, she has healed successfully and is carrying out a healthy and positive relationship. Obviously, some descriptions of the abuse and control are upsetting, so keep that in mind.

The real story in this book is about the bond of sisterhood — mainly between Sally and Gillian, but also between their aunts, Frances and Bridget, and Sally’s daughters, Antonia and Kylie. I am an only child, so reading about deep sibling relationships is always interesting to me. Sometimes they make me sad I’m alone, and sometimes I am grateful. This is one of those stories that makes me sad I’m alone. The support that Sally and Gillian give each other is heartwarming and their frequent disagreements keep it realistic and not maudlin.

Sally and her family have excellent character development and grow to overcome their hang-ups and fears. All the characters learn from each other and come to have a healthier relationship with themselves and each other.